Tag :
Keseharian,
Opinion
- Asep Haryono | Why Do Immigration Officers Use Lethal Force?. My reactions on the Minnesota Tragedy - Powered by Blogger
Disclaimer:
This article represents the author’s personal perspective and is intended for discussion and informational purposes only. It does not encourage hatred, violence, or discrimination in any form.
Happy weekend my friends.This article represents the author’s personal perspective and is intended for discussion and informational purposes only. It does not encourage hatred, violence, or discrimination in any form.
The whole world, including me in Indonesia, have witnessed through social media platforms that In January 2026, an ICE agent in Minneapolis fatally shot Renée Nicole Good during an enforcement operation. Officials claim Good posed an imminent threat, but eyewitness videos show a different perspective, suggesting she was calm before the shooting.
The incident has led to protests and calls for an independent investigation. As of now, the investigation is ongoing, and the community is waiting for more clarity on what happened.
My question is simple. Why Do Immigration Officers Use Lethal Force?
Recently, a tragic incident in Minnesota shocked many people around the world. A woman was fatally shot during an immigration-related operation conducted by U.S. officers. This event has sparked serious attentions, not only about what exactly happened in that case, but also about how immigration enforcement is handled in the United States, and whether such extreme force is really necessary.
As an ordinary observer, I want to reflect on this issue from a human perspective, not a political one instead of I am not good at confrontation. I would like to find an answer to my question mentioned above. Why Do Immigration Officers Use Lethal Force? They are Civilian, Not a Criminal. You are not at war. Why did you do that?
![]() |
| Dramatic video purportedly shows the moment an ICE agent fatally opened fire on a woman in Minneapolis, who DHS says attempted to barrel her SUV into the path of an office.I marked with a circle to show you the guy's firearms. Image courtesy of New Your Post Yputube Channel |
One of the most important points to understand is this:Illegal immigrants are civilians, not armed criminals or terrorists. In most cases, they are unarmed people workers, parents, or families who entered or stayed in a country without proper documents. That is a legal issue, yes, but it is not the same as violent crime. I want to say one more time my friends/ My other big question is: Why do officers need to carry lethal weapons when dealing with unarmed civilians?
From a moral and humanitarian point of view, this feels deeply troubling. Immigration enforcement should be about administrative law, not battlefield tactics.
You guys said it was “Self-Defense”.
O come on.
The U.S. government and law enforcement agencies often explain that officers are armed for self-defense. The argument is that officers never know what situation they will face and must be prepared for danger.But many people find this reasoning difficult to accept in immigration cases.
Self-defense usually applies when there is a clear and immediate threat.
If the person being arrested is unarmed, surrounded by officers, and not committing violence, then using lethal force feels disproportionate. This is why many people describe such actions as excessive, unnecessary, and even cruel.
Militarization of Immigration Enforcement
Another my major concern is the militarization of immigration officers in the United States. Through many videos I have watched recently clearly showed that many ICE agents are equipped with: Firearms, Tactical gear and Military-style equipment. Just like at war zone
This creates an atmosphere of fear and intimidation, especially in immigrant communities. When officers look and act like soldiers, people naturally panic even if they have done nothing violent. Fear escalates situations. Panic leads to mistakes. And mistakes, when weapons are involved, can end in death.
I compare this with countries like Border Security Australia, the difference is striking. Australia also enforces immigration laws strictly. They search for undocumented immigrants and conduct operations. However, in many recorded cases, officers: Do not carry visible lethal weapons. Focus on questioning and verification. No bullet was fired
Militarization of Immigration Enforcement
Another my major concern is the militarization of immigration officers in the United States. Through many videos I have watched recently clearly showed that many ICE agents are equipped with: Firearms, Tactical gear and Military-style equipment. Just like at war zone
This creates an atmosphere of fear and intimidation, especially in immigrant communities. When officers look and act like soldiers, people naturally panic even if they have done nothing violent. Fear escalates situations. Panic leads to mistakes. And mistakes, when weapons are involved, can end in death.
I compare this with countries like Border Security Australia, the difference is striking. Australia also enforces immigration laws strictly. They search for undocumented immigrants and conduct operations. However, in many recorded cases, officers: Do not carry visible lethal weapons. Focus on questioning and verification. No bullet was fired
Use calm, firm communication. The emphasis is on control and procedure, not intimidation. This comparison shows that immigration enforcement does not have to involve deadly force. I love that
As far as I am concerned, In the United States, immigration enforcement is deeply connected to race, history, and systemic inequality. Even when officers say race is not a factor, the outcomes often suggest otherwise.
Communities of color feel targeted. Immigrants feel hunted rather than protected by the law. This erodes trust and creates long-term damage to social cohesion.
After a fatal incident like the one in Minnesota, many people ask: I would like you guys to investiage this issue as soon as possible. We do not have to wait so long for justice even tough you will need more time for Investigations because multiple agencies are involved, Evidence must be reviewed carefully and Legal standards are strict. While this process is important to ensure fairness, long delays also create frustration, anger, and suspicion among the public. Transparency during investigations is essential. Silence only deepens mistrust.
Whether the case will go to trial depends on Evidence, Witness accounts, Body camera footage and Legal interpretation of “use of force”Justice is not guaranteed but public pressure, media attention, and independent investigations can play a crucial role in ensuring accountability. Justice is not just about punishment. It is also about acknowledging wrongdoing and preventing future tragedies.
POV : What the U.S. Government Should Do Next
If the U.S. truly wants to prevent similar tragedies, several changes are necessary like limit the use of lethal weapons in immigration operations, Prioritize de-escalation training, not tactical aggression, Separate immigration enforcement from criminal policing, Ensure independent oversight for any use of deadly force and Treat undocumented immigrants as civilians, not enemies
Immigration is a legal issue. It should not be handled like a war.
At the end of the day, this is not only about laws or borders. It is about human life. A person died. A family lost someone. A community was traumatized. No policy, no law, and no enforcement operation should forget that basic truth. If governments want respect for the law, they must first show respect for human dignity. A Human Issue, Not Just a Legal One
What are your thoughts on this issue?
As far as I am concerned, In the United States, immigration enforcement is deeply connected to race, history, and systemic inequality. Even when officers say race is not a factor, the outcomes often suggest otherwise.
Communities of color feel targeted. Immigrants feel hunted rather than protected by the law. This erodes trust and creates long-term damage to social cohesion.
After a fatal incident like the one in Minnesota, many people ask: I would like you guys to investiage this issue as soon as possible. We do not have to wait so long for justice even tough you will need more time for Investigations because multiple agencies are involved, Evidence must be reviewed carefully and Legal standards are strict. While this process is important to ensure fairness, long delays also create frustration, anger, and suspicion among the public. Transparency during investigations is essential. Silence only deepens mistrust.
Whether the case will go to trial depends on Evidence, Witness accounts, Body camera footage and Legal interpretation of “use of force”Justice is not guaranteed but public pressure, media attention, and independent investigations can play a crucial role in ensuring accountability. Justice is not just about punishment. It is also about acknowledging wrongdoing and preventing future tragedies.
POV : What the U.S. Government Should Do Next
If the U.S. truly wants to prevent similar tragedies, several changes are necessary like limit the use of lethal weapons in immigration operations, Prioritize de-escalation training, not tactical aggression, Separate immigration enforcement from criminal policing, Ensure independent oversight for any use of deadly force and Treat undocumented immigrants as civilians, not enemies
Immigration is a legal issue. It should not be handled like a war.
At the end of the day, this is not only about laws or borders. It is about human life. A person died. A family lost someone. A community was traumatized. No policy, no law, and no enforcement operation should forget that basic truth. If governments want respect for the law, they must first show respect for human dignity. A Human Issue, Not Just a Legal One
What are your thoughts on this issue?
Do you believe immigration enforcement should prioritize humanity and de-escalatio?
Feel free to share your perspective respectfully in the comments below
Happy weekend my friend
Stay safe.
Do not forget to be happy
A Message From Asep Haryono
"Thank you so much for your time here. I really appreciate your precious moment here as well. Please leave any comment down below. Let me hear from you. Greetings from Indonesia"





















