Tag :
Opinion
- Asep Haryono | Did America Exist Because of the Jewish People?- My Opinion - Powered by Blogger
Disclaimer
This article reflects my personal views and understanding based on publicly available information. To be honest, I am not a historian, political analyst, journalist, or international relations expert, so some information or opinions may be incomplete or open to different interpretations.
I shared this article to encourage respectful discussion and the free exchange of ideas, not to promote any political, religious, or ideological agenda. I welcome constructive comments and different perspectives, provided they are expressed with courtesy and mutual respect. Please don't be hesiate to share your ideas, suggestion, and comments here
Thank you one more time my friend for reading.
This article reflects my personal views and understanding based on publicly available information. To be honest, I am not a historian, political analyst, journalist, or international relations expert, so some information or opinions may be incomplete or open to different interpretations.
I shared this article to encourage respectful discussion and the free exchange of ideas, not to promote any political, religious, or ideological agenda. I welcome constructive comments and different perspectives, provided they are expressed with courtesy and mutual respect. Please don't be hesiate to share your ideas, suggestion, and comments here
Thank you one more time my friend for reading.
Happy reading
The U.S. President Donald Trump has repeatedly stated that without the United States, Israel would not survive. There is no doubt that the United States has been Israel's strongest ally, providing unwavering extensive military aid, diplomatic support, intelligence cooperation, and advanced defense technology for many decades. Moreover, while the U.S. is Israel's largest ally, it is not the only country that has supported Israel in various ways.
Recently, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee made a statement on X (formerly Twitter) that attracted worldwide attention. He wrote:"Without the Jewish people, America would never have existed." I have enclosed herewith a copy or screenshoot of the topic that I would like to discuss with
The U.S. President Donald Trump has repeatedly stated that without the United States, Israel would not survive. There is no doubt that the United States has been Israel's strongest ally, providing unwavering extensive military aid, diplomatic support, intelligence cooperation, and advanced defense technology for many decades. Moreover, while the U.S. is Israel's largest ally, it is not the only country that has supported Israel in various ways.
Recently, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee made a statement on X (formerly Twitter) that attracted worldwide attention. He wrote:"Without the Jewish people, America would never have existed." I have enclosed herewith a copy or screenshoot of the topic that I would like to discuss with
 |
| Source GBX |
Many people agreed with his statement, while others strongly disagreed. This raises an important question: Is this statement historically true, or is it simply a personal belief? To answer this question fairly, we need to look at history, facts, and evidence instead of emotions or political opinions.
Who is Mike Huckabee
To understand the statement, it is helpful to know Mike Huckabee's background. Before becoming a politician, Huckabee was a Baptist pastor. Many evangelical Christians believe that Christianity cannot exist without Judaism because Jesus, the apostles, and the earliest followers of Christianity were Jewish.
They also believe the Old Testament forms the foundation of Christian faith. From this religious viewpoint, someone might argue that America's Christian heritage ultimately began with the Jewish people. This is a theological or religious belief.
America Was Founded by Many Different Influences
The United States of America did not suddenly appear overnight. It was created through many events that happened over hundreds of years.
Some of the most important influences were:
Historians agree that America was built from many different cultural, political, and philosophical traditions. No single group or nation can claim full credit for creating the United States.
To understand the statement, it is helpful to know Mike Huckabee's background. Before becoming a politician, Huckabee was a Baptist pastor. Many evangelical Christians believe that Christianity cannot exist without Judaism because Jesus, the apostles, and the earliest followers of Christianity were Jewish.
They also believe the Old Testament forms the foundation of Christian faith. From this religious viewpoint, someone might argue that America's Christian heritage ultimately began with the Jewish people. This is a theological or religious belief.
America Was Founded by Many Different Influences
The United States of America did not suddenly appear overnight. It was created through many events that happened over hundreds of years.
Some of the most important influences were:
• British colonization beginning in 1607.
• English law and political traditions.
• The ideas of the European Enlightenment.
• The American Revolution against Great Britain.
• The writing of the U.S. Constitution.
• English law and political traditions.
• The ideas of the European Enlightenment.
• The American Revolution against Great Britain.
• The writing of the U.S. Constitution.
Historians agree that America was built from many different cultural, political, and philosophical traditions. No single group or nation can claim full credit for creating the United States.
You may read - JEWS, ARABS, and Zionism. clearing up the confusion
 |
| Israel and the US flag side by side. |
The Influence of England
Perhaps the biggest influence on early America was England.
The thirteen colonies that later became the United States were British colonies. The colonists spoke English, followed English laws, and inherited English political traditions.
Important English documents helped shape American democracy. These included the Magna Carta (1215) and the English Bill of Rights (1689). Both documents limited the power of the king and protected certain rights of the people.
The American legal system still reflects many principles from English common law today. Without England, historians generally agree that American history would have looked very different.
Perhaps the biggest influence on early America was England.
The thirteen colonies that later became the United States were British colonies. The colonists spoke English, followed English laws, and inherited English political traditions.
Important English documents helped shape American democracy. These included the Magna Carta (1215) and the English Bill of Rights (1689). Both documents limited the power of the king and protected certain rights of the people.
The American legal system still reflects many principles from English common law today. Without England, historians generally agree that American history would have looked very different.
The Enlightenment Played a Major Role
Another important influence was the European Enlightenment during the 17th and 18th centuries. Thinkers such as John Locke, Montesquieu, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau wrote about freedom, equality, natural rights, and government by the people.
Their ideas greatly influenced the Founding Fathers of the United States. For example, Thomas Jefferson used many Enlightenment ideas when writing the Declaration of Independence in 1776. One famous sentence says: "All men are created equal."
This idea came mainly from Enlightenment philosophy rather than from religious teachings.
The Founding Fathers
The United States was founded by leaders such as George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Adams.
None of these men were Jewish.
They came from different Christian backgrounds, although some were more religious than others.
Their writings show that they were influenced by several sources:
• The Bible
• Greek philosophy
• Roman government
• English law
• Enlightenment thinkers
• Greek philosophy
• Roman government
• English law
• Enlightenment thinkers
Instead of depending on one single source, they combined many ideas into a new system of government.
Did Judaism Influence America?
The answer is yes, however only in certain ways.
Many early American settlers were Christians, especially the Puritans. The Puritans loved reading the Hebrew Bible, also known as the Old Testament. They often compared themselves with the ancient Israelites.
You may read- Judaism vs. Zionism: Why They're Not the Same and Why It Matters
For example, they believed they were leaving oppression in Europe just as Moses led the Israelites out of Egypt. Some American leaders also admired biblical ideas about justice, morality, and freedom. Therefore, Judaism influenced America mainly through the Bible that Christians also consider sacred. However, this does not mean the Jewish people themselves created America.
How Many Jewish People Lived in Colonial America?
Historical records show that the Jewish population in colonial America was very small. By the time of the American Revolution in 1776, only about 2,000 to 3,000 Jews lived among a colonial population of roughly 2.5 million people.
That means Jewish people made up around one-tenth of one percent of the population. Most Jewish communities lived in cities such as New York, Philadelphia, Charleston, Newport, and Savannah. They contributed to local business and trade, but they were not the main political leaders during the founding of the United States.
For example, they believed they were leaving oppression in Europe just as Moses led the Israelites out of Egypt. Some American leaders also admired biblical ideas about justice, morality, and freedom. Therefore, Judaism influenced America mainly through the Bible that Christians also consider sacred. However, this does not mean the Jewish people themselves created America.
How Many Jewish People Lived in Colonial America?
Historical records show that the Jewish population in colonial America was very small. By the time of the American Revolution in 1776, only about 2,000 to 3,000 Jews lived among a colonial population of roughly 2.5 million people.
That means Jewish people made up around one-tenth of one percent of the population. Most Jewish communities lived in cities such as New York, Philadelphia, Charleston, Newport, and Savannah. They contributed to local business and trade, but they were not the main political leaders during the founding of the United States.
Jewish Contributions to America Are Very Important
Although Jewish people were a small minority during America's founding, their later contributions to American society have been enormous.
In science, medicine, law, business, education, entertainment, and technology, Jewish Americans have helped shape the modern United States.
Some famous examples include:
• Albert Einstein, whose scientific work changed modern physics.
• Jonas Salk, who developed one of the first successful polio vaccines.
• Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who became one of the most respected justices on the U.S. Supreme Court.
• Jonas Salk, who developed one of the first successful polio vaccines.
• Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who became one of the most respected justices on the U.S. Supreme Court.
Many Jewish immigrants also helped build businesses, universities, hospitals, and charitable organizations across America.
These achievements deserve recognition and respect.
However, most of these contributions happened long after the United States became an independent nation in 1776. It is not the same as saying that historians have proved America would never have existed without Jewish people.
What Do Historians Say?
Professional historians generally explain America's founding using several major causes.
These include:
• British colonial history.
• English constitutional traditions.
• Enlightenment philosophy.
• Economic conflicts with Britain.
• The American Revolution.
• The leadership of the Founding Fathers.
• English constitutional traditions.
• Enlightenment philosophy.
• Economic conflicts with Britain.
• The American Revolution.
• The leadership of the Founding Fathers.
These are supported by thousands of historical documents, letters, government records, and academic studies. Mainstream historians do not argue that America would never have existed without the Jewish people. Instead, they describe America's birth as the result of many different historical forces working together.
Is Huckabee's Statement really True?
I would not say that what he stated was correct or wrong. The answer depends on how people interpret it.
If the statement is understood literally as a historical claim, the available evidence does not support it. History shows that America was founded through the combined influence of England, Europe, Christianity, classical philosophy, and the political decisions of its founders.
The Jewish people certainly influenced Western civilization and Christianity, but historians do not identify them as the sole or indispensable reason for America's existence. If Huckabee meant his statement in a religious or symbolic sense, then many evangelical Christians would understand what he meant. In that case, the statement reflects a theological opinion rather than a historical conclusion.
My perspective and opinions
History is often more complex than political slogans or social media posts.
The United States owes much to many peoples and traditions. England gave America its language and legal system. The Enlightenment inspired ideas about liberty and democracy. Christianity influenced moral thinking. Greek and Roman civilizations shaped political philosophy. Immigrants from every continent later strengthened the nation through their work and talents.
Jewish people have made remarkable contributions to the United States and continue to do so today. Their role in American science, medicine, business, education, and public life is widely respected.
However, based on historical evidence, it is not accurate to say that America would never have existed without the Jewish people.
Such a statement expresses a religious or political belief rather than a conclusion supported by mainstream historical scholarship.
When discussing history, it is important to distinguish between faith, opinion, and verifiable evidence. Respecting every community's contributions while remaining faithful to the historical record allows us to better understand how the United States truly came into existence
I need your own opinion my friends
What do you think about Mike Huckabee's statement?
Do you agree that the Jewish people were essential to the creation of America, or do you believe the nation's founding was shaped by many different historical influences? I would love to hear your thoughts.
Please share your opinion in the comments below. Let's keep our discussion respectful, constructive, and based on facts, history, and mutual understanding. Every thoughtful perspective is welcome..
A Message From Asep Haryono
"Thank you so much for your time here. I really appreciate your precious moment here as well. Please leave any comment down below. Let me hear from you. Greetings from Indonesia"
From 1846 to 1848 the American war against Mexico was financed by Jewish people. At the end of the war Mexico was forced to cede: California, Texas, Nevada, Utah, New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado and parts of Wyoming, Kansas, and Oklahoma.
ReplyDeleteTwo decades later the American civil war started because 11 states declared secession. In 1865 the North won the American War of Secession, when Confederate General Robert E. Lee surrendered. This Union victory, which preserved the United States as a single, undivided nation, was financed by jewish billionaires. This a fact. This history.
In addition, Jewish financiers, particularly of German origin, played a defining role in financing the great American railways during the 19th and early 20th centuries, the 1st and the 2nd world war.
Thank you for taking the time to share your perspective and historical references. I appreciate your thoughtful contribution to the discussion. My blog post was simply intended to encourage readers to reflect on the historical influence of Jewish people in America's development. Thank you again for reading and commenting.
Delete