Tag :
Indonesia
- Asep Haryono | Kezia Syifa Maghfira May Lose Indonesian Citizenship After Joining the U.S. Army - Powered by Blogger
Disclaimer:
This article is written for informational and educational purposes only. The information presented is based on publicly available sources, general legal references, and media reports at the time of writing. It does not constitute legal advice or an official statement from any government authority. Individual cases related to citizenship status may vary depending on specific facts, official investigations, and legal decisions by the relevant authorities. Readers are encouraged to consult official government sources or legal professionals for the most accurate and up-to-date information. Please sit and relax as you navigate this post. Enjoy. Thank you. (Asep Haryono)
Kezia Syifa Maghfir? Who is she anyway?
Well, Indonesian social media has recently been abuzz with the story of an Indonesian woman, Kezia Syifa Maghfira, who chose to pursue a career as a soldier in the United States Army. While many people praise her courage and achievement, this decision also carries serious legal consequences related to her Indonesian citizenship.
Kezia Syifa Maghfira, originally from Tangerang, West Java,Indonesia decided to join the U.S. Army at a young age. Her story went viral after photos and videos of her wearing an American military uniform circulated widely on social media. Many Indonesians expressed admiration and pride, seeing her journey as inspiring and impressive.
![]() |
Kezia Syifa Maghfira, from Tangerang, West Java, Indonesia, decided to join the U.S. Army. Her decision went viral in Indonesia and was widely reported by local media, sparking intense public discussion. Photo courtesy of Media Indonesia Youtube Channel
Find the video from Media Indonesia Channel
Find the video from Media Indonesia Channel
However, joining a foreign military is not a new issue for Indonesia.
This situation has happened before. Former Indonesian Marine Satria Arta Kumbara lost his Indonesian citizenship after joining Russian military forces without permission from the President of Indonesia. The Minister of Law and Human Rights later confirmed that, under Indonesian law, serving in a foreign military without approval leads to the automatic loss of Indonesian citizenship.
Read also Satria Arta Kumbara, the Mercenary Who Fought for Russia Is an Indonesian National.
Behind the praise and viral excitement, there is a serious legal issue that many people may not fully understand: the risk of losing Indonesian citizenship. What Indonesian law actually says, why this issue happens, and what young Indonesians should know before making similar decisions
My friends.....
I have no idea if People often say that joining the U.S. Army is not easy. I really have no idea about it, however from my perspective and assumption It requires strong physical ability, mental strength, discipline, and commitment. For some Indonesians living abroad, the U.S. military is also seen as a pathway to a better life, stable income, education, and faster access to a Green Card or U.S. citizenship.
From a personal achievement point of view, this looks impressive. But from a legal point of view in Indonesia, the situation is very sensitive. Indonesia has clear rules about citizenship. These rules are written in Law No. 12 of 2006 on Indonesian Citizenship.
According to Article 23(d) of this law, an Indonesian citizen can lose their citizenship if they enter service in a foreign military without permission from the President of the Republic of Indonesia (Now is Prabowo Subianto). This means joining any foreign army , including the U.S. Army , can cause automatic loss of Indonesian citizenship if there is no official presidential approval.
The Oath of Allegiance Issue
Another important point is the oath of allegiance. When someone joins the U.S. military, they must take an oath that includes loyalty to the United States and obedience to its Constitution and military command. Under Indonesian law, this matters a lot. Article 23(f) states that Indonesian citizenship can be lost if someone voluntarily swears loyalty to another country. So even if a person does not immediately become a U.S. citizen, taking the military oath alone can be enough to trigger the loss of Indonesian citizenship.
Dual Citizenship? Its a Confusion
This is where many people get confused. Indonesia does not recognize dual citizenship for adults. Only children can temporarily hold dual citizenship under special conditions, and they must choose one nationality when they become adults.
So if an adult Indonesian joins a foreign military and later becomes a citizen of another country, Indonesian citizenship is usually lost automatically.
From Indonesia’s perspective, it is seen as a transfer of loyalty away from the Republic of Indonesia. This difference in legal systems often causes shock when such cases go viral.
This is not just theory. Indonesia has handled several real cases where citizens lost their citizenship after joining foreign militaries without permission. Government officials, including the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, have repeatedly confirmed that the law is clear and has been enforced.
Remember the rule is real.
An Indonesian citizen can lose their citizenship if they join the U.S. Army or any foreign military without presidential permission, especially if they take an oath of allegiance. However, each case still depends on details such as whether the person officially enlisted, whether they took the military oath, and whether presidential permission existed. Social media often simplifies these details, which can lead to misunderstanding.
This viral story is a reminder that big life decisions have serious legal consequences, especially when they involve another country’s military. Chasing dreams is important, and building a better future is natural. But understanding the law is just as important.
Before joining any foreign military, Indonesians should learn the legal consequences, consult official sources, and think carefully about their citizenship status. Once citizenship is lost, getting it back is not simple.
I share this viral story because it may be interesting for fellow bloggers abroad, especially those in the United States. For American bloggers reading this, I would love to hear your perspective and opinions as U.S. citizens.
A Message From Asep Haryono
"Thank you so much for your time here. I really appreciate your precious moment here as well. Please leave any comment down below. Let me hear from you. Greetings from Indonesia"










If a young man or woman joins the US military, they lose their Indonesian citizenship. I wonder if they will immediately receive US citizenship?
ReplyDeleteAnd if they don't, and they get sick or injured, where will they go? They won't be allowed into Indonesia, and they'll be expelled from the US.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment, Irina. You raise an important and very real concern.
DeleteBy the way, I awake early morning here. Its 1.21 AM. Its still dark outside my house
Joining the U.S. military does not automatically grant U.S. citizenship. In most cases, non-citizens serve first as permanent residents and may apply for citizenship later through a legal process. During service, they are covered by U.S. military healthcare and support systems, including treatment for illness or injury.
From the Indonesian side, citizenship loss depends on legal findings, not social media reports alone. Each case is reviewed individually. So the situation is complex, and your question highlights why this topic deserves careful discussion rather than quick assumptions.
I didn't know about this story Asep. It seems strange she would want to join the US Army? Considering what is going on over there? As Irina said above, will she get US Citizenship? Or will she have not Citizenship? It's a strange one.
ReplyDeleteHope you are well and your week is going well. I have been doing physiotherapy to help my broken ankle start moving again. Slowly getting there but going to be a long time before I can walk properly again. I am taking each day as it comes and celebrating the positives each day. :-D
Hi again Mrs Ananka, thank you so much for reading and for your thoughtful comment.
DeleteHow is it going?
Yes, it does feel unusual to many people, especially given the current global situation. Joining the U.S. Army does not automatically mean someone receives U.S. citizenship. In most cases, it is a long legal process, and citizenship is not guaranteed. That uncertainty is exactly why this topic raises so many questions and concerns.
I’m really sorry to hear about your ankle, but I truly admire your positive mindset.
Taking things day by day and celebrating small progress is the best way forward. Wishing you a smooth recovery and stronger steps ahead.
Take good care, and I hope the rest of your week treats you kindly
Such an interesting story. She sounds very much on her own on this one. I hope she is doing well. & perhaps thinking twice about her home country being where she should be. Thanks for the info. I can see it would be a big story there, especially with what''s going on in the States.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Ellie, I really appreciate your thoughtful response.
DeleteYes, it does seem like a very lonely and difficult position to be in. Big decisions like this often come with consequences that are not fully visible at the beginning. My intention in writing this article was not to judge her choice, but to explain why it became such a big topic in Indonesia, especially because citizenship and national identity are sensitive issues there.
Thank you again for reading and sharing your perspective and it means a lot.
She has youth on her side. Even so these must be difficult questions to face. Our National guard is facing more fear than they have ever had to face these days. Thanks for your story.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Caitlin & Megan, for sharing your perspective.
DeleteYou’re absolutely right youth can bring courage, but it can also mean facing very difficult questions earlier in life. With the current global situation, even national guards and military forces are under pressures that many people have never experienced before. That reality adds another layer of complexity to decisions like this.
I appreciate you taking the time to read the article and share your thoughts. Thank you for stopping by.
I hope she doesn't later regret her decision.
ReplyDelete